Interview with Artist Melissa A. Benson

Melissa A. Benson is one of the original 25 Magic artists. Her paintings illustrate 63 Magic cards, printed from Alpha to Urza's block. Some of them, especially her earliest pieces, count among the most iconic creatures of all time: Nightmare, Lord of Atlantis, and the mighty Shivan Dragon.

While her Magic days lie in the past, Melissa A. Benson is still active in the world of cardboard, as we'll learn from the following interview …

lord of atlantis - shivan dragon

Dr. Exhume: Mrs. Benson, please tell us how you came to illustrating.

Melissa Benson: Well, music and art have been my two loves. Right out of high school I decided to pursue music. I received my associate degree, tutored my classmates in music theory and harmony. Although I play woodwinds, I majored on bassoon with an eye toward conducting. When it came to getting a job, I found the music industry too ugly to pursue professionally.

Fortunately, I took art classes all through the music program, and decided to go for my associates degree in art. So many of the required courses were the same for art and music that I was able to get the art degree quickly. And art was a better fit for me since you can do it alone. Music usually involves other people. I was always drawing as a kid, I decorated the wallpaper in the living room—much to my mother's displeasure. I was very fortunate to have supportive parents for both music and art. Mythical animals and anthropomorphic creatures were my favorites.


Dr. Exhume: You started illustrating Magic cards with the very first set, Alpha. How did you get involved in Magic: The Gathering?

Melissa Benson: I was looking for work doing paperback book covers for fantasy novels. My husband was a comics fan and dealer, and the comic book store had some gaming items. They looked like a good fit, so I took down some addresses and contacted them. One of them said they'd send me a five-page list of gaming companies, so I said sure. Then I started sending out queries to them all.

Jesper [Myrfors] at Wizards of the Coast got back to me. He said that he was the art director for a game that was in the works, and that my work looked like it would be a good fit for it. Soon after that, he got back to me and I took seven cards. In hindsight, I should have taken more. I had the time. But Wizards was only paying $50, and $50 worth of stock, per illustration. I didn't feel like I could spend more time on those cards than that. I had to look for jobs that paid better. Sigh …

cloud of faeries

Dr. Exhume: You illustrated many highly iconic creatures like Shivan Dragon, Lord of Atlantis, Nightmare, and Cloud of Faeries. Do you have a favorite among your Magic artworks? Is there a piece you do not like anymore?

Melissa Benson: I don't have a favorite image from the game. I still really like the ideas behind them all, but after 25+ years I see some irritating mistakes I made, and how they should have been done. I wouldn't say I dislike them, I am just kinda embarrassed by some now. If I had them to do over, many would be altogether different.

cat warriors

Dr. Exhume: I like your artworks from Legends in particular—Ivory Guardians, Elven Riders, Cat Warriors. Do you have a special relationship to a certain card or set? Xira Arien sure looks like fun.

Melissa Benson: There is a special relationship with all of them at the time they are being done. That was the beauty of being able to pick the images rather than having them assigned arbitrarily. I like doing pin-ups and creatures, and for the most part, that is what I always chose. I like to make my creatures unusual. For Xira, I thought of those moths with the fuzzy antennas, and noticed how much they resembled a medieval headdress, and it spiraled out from there. Ivory Guardians was originally titled the Skyros Titan. That is why he is blue. It is also why there is only one. It is also why he is huge. It was really annoying when they changed the name. It was a pet peeve of mine.

xira arien ivory guardians

Dr Exhume: Is there a colleague you admire—whether from back in the day or more recent, from Magic or elsewhere?

Melissa Benson: Quinton Hoover. Without a doubt, hands down. We talked about doing a piece together, but never got around to it. I would pencil it, he would ink it, and I would color it. The closest we got was when Quinton, Mark Poole, and I were at a show in Vermont, and we all did a piece together. Quinton offered to ink it, and Mark and I couldn't say yes fast enough. You can see the print on my website.

"Mischief in the Mountains" by Hoover, Poole, Benson

Dr. Exhume: That's a phenomenal choice! What are you currently working on?

Melissa Benson: Besides trying to catch up on a five-month backlog of commissions, I have done many of the cards for the new game Sorcery: Contested Realms. The game is designed to look like an old-school card game made in the nineties, with the varied, hand-painted, and iconic art of that era. There are several of the original Magic artists working on it, and there will be a Kickstarter for it in 2021. You can see some of my art for it on their their Facebook page and on this page of my website. I'll be putting up pieces a little at a time. Most images are characters/creatures or artifacts.

"Screaming Skull" by Melissa Benson, from the upcoming Sorcery: Contested Realms

Dr. Exhume: Thank you so much for your time and for the nice conversation!

Opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily Cardmarket.


To leave your comment please log into your Cardmarket account or create a new account.

ggurmeister(08.03.2021 08:20)

I am the owner of one of the color study finals of Kjeldoran dead and had a lot of contact with Melissa over the past 2 years and i also own the sketch and color study for ivory guardians / Skyros Titan.
Great person, great art.
Also knows a lot of extra facts about the art she drew, 25 years after the deed :)

ctobehn(08.03.2021 12:10)

Ggurmeister Agreed! Lucky you...!

Pandam(08.03.2021 06:47)

Thank you for the article! It is always a delight "seeing" behind the scenes.

ctobehn(08.03.2021 12:07)

Pandam Thank you! With pleasure!

Thorond0r(08.03.2021 01:05)

Ohhhh, too short. We need more from the Magic Queen!

ctobehn(08.03.2021 09:04)

Thorond0r Thanks for the comment. The interview has to fit in the scedule of the artist. I found out that the sweet spot to even get a response on a request is six to seven questions. The longer interviews I did were offers of the specific artist to do a more comprehensive questionnaire.

Thorond0r(08.03.2021 11:26)

Ctobehn thanks for the interview, such an icon she is.

ctobehn(09.03.2021 07:47)

Thorond0r For sure!