The Golden/Silver/Bronze Age of Magic

In light of recent announcements, last year's Secret Lair: Walking Dead looks increasingly like it was the dawn of a new era: the age of crossovers. It fueled a lot of chatter and ramblings, for example about what constitutes "the Golden Age" of Magic. Let's try to determine different periods!

The classic example of a periodization system is human history by periods. Typical classifications distinguish between the Stone Age, the Bronze Age, and the Iron Age, or Antiquity, the Middle Ages, and modern times.


armageddon clock

While determining different periods in Magic might be an absolutely subjective barber shop topic, I admit that thinking about it was a lot of fun. Furthermore it helps rearranging thoughts about times and sets from the past. The most important question I asked myself was this one: what actually makes an era an era in Magic? I decided to search for cutting incidents. A caesura. A break with the rules or habits! When were Magic players most angry? ("This does not look like a Magic card!!!")

Using the labels "gold, silver, bronze" (and "opal") I collected the most important key aspects, changes, and annoyances, but also the big caesuras, which ended the specific eras—in my personal opinion. The most notorious innovations and upsets of every era are summed up under "outrage" and "most notable." Since I am an art geek when it comes to Magic, I can already reveal that my choices are related to the aesthetics of the game.

The Golden Age of Magic

Alpha to Onslaught


Tolarian Academy/Necropotence
Problematic cards already existed in the olden days

Determining the Golden Age was the most difficult part for me. Some of the most fundamental innovations were given birth around these first years of Magic: the dual lands, the first set symbol (Arabian Nights), then the colored set symbol in Exodus, and the foil card in Urza's Legacy. It was obvious to me that it had to start from the very beginning with Alpha and include every following set including Urza's block, but I was not exactly sure where to let it end. At first I felt that it ended right after Urza's block.

Then I recalled that Masques block, although noticeable weaker, was still very pretty above all. Especially the aristocratic theme of Mercadian Masques was cool and a real beauty in my eyes. While Invasion still felt special to me, the following blocks Odyssey and Onslaught were already lacking that special Magic feel and appeal to me. They delivered highly iconic and powerful Magic cards like Entomb and the fetch lands though.

Ultimately I feel that the changed card frame in Eighth Edition was the biggest caesura until then. To me it was the death stroke and a catastrophe to Magic back in the day. My perspective on that luckily changed with time.

Outrage: The reprint set Chronicles caused a massive decrease in value of cards, which led to the creation of the Reserved List (a very controversial topic today, since ages, and probably forever). Urza's "Combo Winter" made players leave the game because of massive power level issues. Power level issues were also a thing (or not a thing) when it came to "Necro Summer" (Necropotence was arguably too strong) as well as for Fallen Empires, Homelands, and Mercadian Masques (these sets were considered too weak).

Most notable: legendary sets (Alpha/Beta/Unlimited/Revised, Arabian Nights, Antiquities, Legends, Ice Age, Mirage, the Tempest and Urza's blocks), the Power Nine, dual lands, fetch lands, the Reserved List, foils, color pie inconsistencies, introduction of colored set symbols in Exodus

Caesura: frame adjustment with Eighth Edition

The Silver Age

Eighth Edition/Mirrodin to Theros


liliana of the veil jace, the mind sculptor

I must admit that I was not entirely sure if this Silver Age wasn't the real—or another—Golden Age of Magic, at least part of it. I can relate to anyone arguing so. One could definitely make a case that this was or still was a Golden Age for Magic. The sets of this era were creative, the art was still gritty, the paper quality was still great, and the sets were relatively well balanced for the most part, with some exceptions in Affinity and phyrexian mana.

The most important innovation of this era was without a doubt the planeswalker card type launched in Lorwyn. It was one of the biggest game changers and a defining moment for Magic in general. If not overnight, planeswalkers became highly iconic. Just think of all the Lilianas, Jaces, and Nissas at games conventions nowadays. But as always, when things change drastically, players leave the game, because they cannot cope or don't want to deal with the change.

With Return to Ravnica Wizards also started their "print to demand" system and gave printers a hard time. Print runs went through the roof. What ended this era for me? Here we go again: I can't look over the fact that Magic lost appeal again because of a more functional, cleaned up, less aesthetic card frame with M15.

Outrage: all in all quite little, Affinity and Cawblade, phyrexian mana, M10 rules change, introduction of mythic rarity

Most notable: very consistent, creation of some of the most decisive sets ever (especially Mirrodin, Time Spiral, Lorwyn, Scars of Mirrodin, as well as the original Ravnica, Zendikar, and Innistrad), Dredge!, shock lands, enemy fetch lands, Masters sets, planeswalker invention

Caesura: frame adjustment with M15

The Bronze Age

M15/Khans of Tarkir to War of the Spark


Hogaak/Wrenn and Six

This era brought the contemporary Magic card frame. While it definitely is functional and clean, I do not like it from an aesthetic perspective. Looking at it, I still get the feeling that something is missing on the lower end of the card. To me it looks like a test card. Unfinished. The uncontinous boarder still rings the aesthetic alarm bell in me. It was roughly around this time too that the illustrations became less gritty and less textured. I don't want to go into detail on the topic of Magic becoming more lighthearted, though, because Gianluca Aicardi already did.

The Bronze Age (Modern Horizons inclued) also delivered a still continuing stream of problematic cards. Many of them saw multi-format bannings. Others, like Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath in Legacy for example, remain on the radar of many players. The most important innovation of this era was the systematic launch of lottery cards. They first appeared in Battle for Zendikar (Expeditions). Kaladesh (Masterpieces) and Amonkhet (Invocations) followed until Wizards discontinued the project. Later Ultimate Masters brought back the lottery card in form of the so-called box topper. It was the first sparkle of a new dawn, although Modern Horizons and War of the Spark came later.

Other points worth mentioning are the clearly tangible change of paper quality since M15 and Nexus of Fate—the first highly relevant tournament card not found in boosters since Mana Crypt!

Outrage: Eldrazi Winter, failed Masters sets Iconic Masters and Masters 25 (turning out pretty strong later), quality issues (paper quality down), Amonkhet Invocations, power level and beginning of problematic cards being printed again (Karn, the Great Creator, Narset, Parter of Veils, Teferi, Time Raveler, Wrenn and Six, Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis, Arcum's Astrolabe, Veil of Summer) culminating in multi-format bannings

Most notable: Dominaria and War of the Spark as standout sets, Eldrazi Winter, introduction of lottery cards in Battle for Zendikar

Caesura: introduction of box toppers and collector boosters

The Opal Era

Throne of Eldraine to Present


Rick, Steadfast Leader

Because of it's colorful and shiny appearance I want to name this era "opal." This ongoing period was kind of initiated by the introduction of the Ultimate Masters box topper. It ushered in a new era in which every set has one or more very special chase cards. These are full-art editions for the most part. Adding Battle for Zendikar, Kaladesh, and Amonkhet to this era (because of the the Expeditions, Masterpieces, and Invocations) is defensible too.

This era also standardized the release of collector boosters for every set and introduced the Secret Lair Drops to the market, which later sparked the whole conversation about different eras in Magic by adding The Walking Dead to Magic. Technically, there were crossovers before. Just think of Frankenstein's Monster. But all the Godzilla stuff from Ikoria took it to a whole new level, and Secret Lair: Walking Dead took it to another level still.

You can like or dislike the fact that Wizards started to sell cards directly to players, but you can't deny the creativity behind some of the Secret Lair Drops like Party Hard, Shred Harder. As a metal head I was stunned the first time I saw these. I really like how they continuously test new waters with this. The most recent innovation of this era is the "etched" card from Commander Legends.


anguished unmaking decimate

Outrage: problematic cards (Once Upon a Time, Oko, Thief of Crowns, Fires of Invention, Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath, Omnath, Locus of Creation …), too many products to keep up with

Most notable: Crossovers! Secret Lair Drops!


Walking Dead

Conclusion

Use of the saying "everything is relative" might be inflated, but it is true nonetheless. I was shocked the first time I saw the new card frame in Eighth Edition and Mirrodin. Today Mirrodin is one of my favorite sets of all time. I was even more dismayed, maybe a little bit sick, when I saw the contemporary frame and I still would change it if I was able to, but I am aware that the frame might be modified again. Maybe, in a year from now, I am crying for the lost M15 frame.

We should not forget to appreciate the fact that Magic is still around and going strong after so many years. Maybe, while I'm writing these lines searching for the "Golden Age of Magic" I am currently living in one. Arthur Schopenhauer described this dilemma the best: You feel pain, but you do not feel painlessness. You don't realize when you are satisfied. You don't feel when you are healthy. But you do feel when you are ill. The negative aspects always surpass the positive. You might only see the golden years when they already lie in the past.

Iron Maiden refererenced this thought more poetically than I did in their wondeful song "Wasted Years":

So understand
Don't waste your time always searching for those wasted years
Face up, make your stand
And realize you're living in the golden years

Wizards tends to make weird market decisions from time to time and they may not manufacture products for everybody these days, but they always find a way to attract players. New and old. This shows specifically in the way they also address old-border fundamentalists like me by including old-framed cards in sets like Mystery Booster or on "The List." In my opinion the hottest take on this is Time Spiral Remastered. It delivers reprints of staples like Chalice of the Void in the old brown artifact frame although it orignially featured the lovely shallow artifact silver of Mirrodin. That's a real stroke of genius by Wizards! I can't wait to see more of this.

If Magic really continues to diversify its product line like this, most people who are interested in new cards should be happy in one way or another. Even if you dislike the idea of a crossover, I want to encourage everybody to look for the positive aspects, because you might find you're living in the golden years. Enjoy them!


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily Cardmarket.



20 Comments

To leave your comment please log into your Cardmarket account or create a new account.

Cortex88(13.03.2021 12:05)

In the market is usual to hear this:
- GOLDEN AGE: Limited Edition Alpha to Fallen Empires (Old School cards);
- SILVER AGE: All the other cards with the old frame.
I agree with this view!

lamule55(11.03.2021 13:09)(Edited: 11.03.2021 19:15)

Really good and optimistic article. I'm on board with Magic since high school 1996 (with some small gaps). I've always loved this game despite mana screw, bannings, new card frames, unbalanced colors, burned money...
I can thank to destiny that I live in times with MtG. Without MtG we would miss that entertaiment.
BTW I'm really looking for magic LotR set. I can not explain why... But I would like to start collecting it right now:)

jamaisbon(11.03.2021 12:19)

Hello Christian, very nice article, I really liked the philosophic tone ! It fits very well with Mtg which is kind of a philosophical game where you can't have the most fun without wisdom and knowledge. It's a difficult exercice to define eras and golden ages, we can find many objective facts to do so like you did, but at some point, it will become subjective because we all tend to identify the golden age as the good all days, meaning the days we were part of. I really enjoyed your mention of Schopenhauer (which Magic Card do you think he would be ?), but I'm french so I will refer to Proust and would say that in my case the Mtg madeleine would be The Mirage and Tempest blocks. Thinking about it brings me nostalgia which is sometimes a good feeling, but it can also develop in kind of a "search for lost time" and it's important to be able to adapt to the present days. Mtg has still a lot to offer, it's a complex, deep and solid game, and if I will always have a special feeling about the old days of the game, I think as long as the community stays passionate, welcoming and gathered (and as long as Wizards stays creative and respectful of that community), there will be a lot more magic eras to live for all who love this game.

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(12.03.2021 08:46)

Jamaisbon Thank you! Very lovely comment! Schopenhauer is probably the guy you see on "Dystopia"

jamaisbon(13.03.2021 15:31)

Probably ! That man from "Dystopia" sure looks seriously tormented by deep and complex existential problems :)

Kristallini(11.03.2021 11:03)

Great article, Its very refreshing to read something so optimistic and positive in these days where Magic gets a lot of hate from fans for its latest developments. Im also not a great Fan of the crossovers, because I think Magic should be proud of its own lore, style and feeling and not try to be something its not, but I can also see that new players are maybe attracted to the game this way, and this is always great.

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(12.03.2021 08:59)

Kristallini Thank you! I'm glad that positive tone was clear.

giangaleazzo(11.03.2021 09:19)

Thank you for the very nice article, i enjoyed it very much!
Totally agree: every MTG products have its positive or interesting point.
I personally feel the lack of the first editions naïf illustration style, but all the late boxtoppers / Secret Lairs / alternative arts solutions are counterbalancing it with new possibilities (for the pain of our wallets)

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(12.03.2021 09:02)

Giangaleazzo Thank you! Agreed. Can relate to that.

isellubuy(11.03.2021 07:53)

I remember the outrage caused bin the "golden age" when the inerrupt disappeared and rules changed to simplify the game to reach a larger number of younger customers.

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(11.03.2021 08:35)

Isellubuy Thank you for your comment. The moment they canceled the interrupt, Magic died...!

benjamingjake(11.03.2021 19:14)

@ctobehn: great article thank you for this. Actually I was surprised to learn in 2017 when I rejoined the game that Interrupts no longer exist (kind of replaced by split second). Though Wizards need to be cautious with the F. I. R. E. (= power creep) strategy. This might be profitable in the short run and attract new players plus increase shareholder value for Hasbro shareholders ( yes, this is also a reason for all these fancy additions and extras). But in the long run it could ruin the game for good!? I was kind of annoyed to learn that I could place all the "Shivan Dragon", "Royal Assasin", "Mahamoti Djinn", "Serra Angel" creatures (Revised/ Fourth edition) aside to the bulk cards - well just "needed" "Snapcasters", "Goyfs" and move on :-)

FledglingOsprey(11.03.2021 03:44)

Great read and good (creative) use of card references throughout, thoroughly enjoyed that!

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(11.03.2021 08:33)

FledglingOsprey Thank you!

lfccruz(11.03.2021 02:17)

Great article.
If I had to define a few MTG eras they would be exact the same as yours. I still think the correct would be subdivide the Golden era as follows:
- Alpha .. The Dark: low print run.
- Fallen Empires .. Urza’s Destiny: no more inclusions to the reserved list.
- Mercadian Masques .. Onslaught: end of old frame.

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(11.03.2021 08:32)

Lfccruz Thank you! That's a very good distinction in my opinion. I agree.

sal196(11.03.2021 01:51)

I think it's very important for people worried about the new upcoming crossovers to remember that Magic drew from other sources right from the start - many Alpha cards have flavor text quoting from real world poetry (Dragon Whelp, Bog Wraith, Scathe Zombies etc), then Arabian Nights featured lots of cards from that book (Aladdin, Sindbad, Shahrazad etc) as well as the Sandman comic (City in a Bottle). Legends then quotes from lots of books, including the Bible (!) on Durkwood Boards, and John Milton's Paradise Lost on Hellfire. Finally as you noted, The Dark has Frankenstein's Monster - a character from another book. So this is really a natural evolution :)

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(12.03.2021 08:51)

Sal196 Thank you! Good points. Loved the quotes!

MagicCardChris(11.03.2021 00:07)

Good article

Dr-Exhume
ctobehn(12.03.2021 08:49)

MagicCardChris Thank you!

cardPreview